Every tax lien investor faces the same question sooner or later: should I hold this lien and wait for redemption, or sell it now and free up my capital? There’s no universal answer. Understanding how to weigh timing, returns, and goals will help you make the decision that fits your strategy.
Holding a lien until redemption can be the most straightforward path. If the property is strong, the interest rate attractive, and the owner likely to pay, patience usually pays off. Redeemed liens can deliver consistent, predictable returns — often higher than traditional investments — with relatively little effort once you’ve done your due diligence. This is the “slow and steady” route, ideal for investors building long-term wealth through compounding re-investments.
But sometimes, selling a lien early makes more sense. Maybe you need liquidity to enter a new market, or perhaps the lien is tied up longer than expected. There’s an active secondary market for tax lien certificates, and selling can provide a faster turnaround, even if it means taking a smaller profit. It’s about freeing up capital to keep your investment cycle moving.
The decision often comes down to ROI and timeline. Ask yourself: how much interest has this lien already earned, and how much more could it earn if held to redemption? Is the potential return worth the wait, or could that same money perform better if reinvested in newer, faster-turning liens?
External factors also matter. If property values in the area are declining or the owner seems unlikely to redeem, holding could mean tying up funds for little reward. On the other hand, in stable markets with strong redemption history, waiting it out could deliver a solid, predictable payoff.
For seasoned investors, a balanced approach works best. Keep a mix. Hold the liens with healthy margins and sell the ones that have plateaued or no longer fit your strategy. The goal is to keep your capital active and your risk managed, not to cling to every lien until the bitter end.
Ultimately, deciding whether to hold or sell isn’t about impatience, it’s about intention. Each choice should align with your broader plan: steady cash flow, reinvestment potential, and your comfort with time horizons.
Tax lien investing rewards strategy over emotion. When you make your hold-or-sell decisions with clear data and long-term goals in mind, you’ll find your portfolio works harder for you.
This blog is for informational purposes only and should not be relied upon as financial or investment advice. Real estate investing carries risks, and individual results will vary. Always consult with your team of professionals before making investment decisions. The authors and distributors of this material are not liable for any losses or damages that may occur as a result of relying on this information.

